How to Choose a Pinterest Ads Agency (and the Red Flags)

Hire the operator, not the pitch.

Choose a Pinterest ads agency on three things: the people who will actually run your account have hands-on Pinterest experience, they fix your tracking before they spend, and they report on new-customer revenue instead of whichever attribution window looks best. Most bad Pinterest engagements fail on one of those three, not on bidding tactics. The red flags are easy to spot once you know what to ask, and the questions below are the ones I’d want a founder to ask us.

Why does Pinterest need a specialist at all?

Pinterest looks like paid social, but it behaves more like search. People come to plan a purchase, not to scroll. Pinterest reported 640 million monthly active users in Q2 2026, up 11% year over year. At its September advertiser summit the company said those users run more than 80 billion searches a month, more than half of them commercial, and over 96% unbranded.

That changes how the account should be run. Catalog quality, product titles and Pin metadata do more of the targeting work than audience settings. Learning periods are slower than Meta’s. Results show up later than the click. An agency that runs Pinterest with a Meta playbook (fast creative churn, tight weekly kill rules, judging on 1-day ROAS) usually shuts off good campaigns before they mature.

The platform is also changing quickly, which raises the bar:

  • Performance+ now carries roughly 30% of Pinterest’s lower-funnel revenue, and Pinterest says adopters grew lower-funnel spend at nearly twice the rate of non-adopters.
  • Value-based bidding can now optimize to an advertiser’s own source of truth, such as customer lifetime value or profit per order, after rolling out in Q1 2026.
  • Visual search ads were announced on September 17, 2026 and are rolling out in beta. They place your products in search results and Pin close-ups, where people compare options.

What questions should I ask a Pinterest ads agency?

Ask these in the first call. The answers tell you more than any case study deck.

  1. Who will run my account day to day, and how many Pinterest accounts have they personally managed? You want a name, not a department. Ask whether that person has run catalog and Performance+ campaigns at your spend level.
  2. What will you check before launching? The right answer starts with the Pinterest tag, the Conversions API, catalog health and event deduplication. If the first answer is creative, they’re skipping the foundation.
  3. Which attribution window will you report on, and why? Make them commit before launch. More on this below.
  4. How long until we judge results, and what happens in weeks two to six? A good agency sets a 60 to 90 day evaluation window and tells you what normal volatility looks like during learning.
  5. How will you prove Pinterest is adding new customers? Look for blended MER, new-customer revenue from Shopify or your CRM, post-purchase surveys, and holdout tests when budget allows.
  6. How do you manage a large catalog? Ask how they find products that eat spend without converting, and whether they maintain a separate Pinterest feed.
  7. What’s your relationship with Pinterest itself? Agencies with active Pinterest partner contacts can escalate account suspensions, billing problems and tracking bugs faster than a support ticket.
  8. What are your terms? Minimum spend, minimum commitment and how you exit. Clear terms are a sign the agency expects to earn the renewal. Ours are a $10K/month minimum ad spend and a 3-month minimum, then month-to-month.

What are the red flags when hiring a Pinterest ads agency?

Most of these show up in the sales process if you’re looking for them.

Red flag Why it matters What good looks like
Reports only Pinterest’s default attribution window The default is 30-day click plus 1-day view. View-through credit can make results look several times better than click-only results. Reports click-only and click-plus-view side by side, then ties both to new-customer revenue.
Launches before auditing tracking A broken tag or missing Conversions API means the algorithm optimizes on bad data from day one. Checks tag and API events, event IDs and deduplication before spending.
Treats Pinterest like Meta Weekly kill rules and constant creative swaps reset learning on a slower platform. Fewer, stronger creatives run longer; changes are batched.
Promises ROAS in month one Pinterest ramps slowly and pays back over a longer window. Sets a 60 to 90 day evaluation plan with leading indicators for the early weeks.
Senior people pitch, juniors run it The expertise you bought isn’t the expertise you get. You meet the person who will manage the account before you sign.
Never looks at the catalog In Performance+, one bad product can absorb a large share of spend. Reviews spend by product and excludes or fixes underperformers.

How should a Pinterest agency handle tracking and attribution?

This is where I’d spend most of your diligence. Pinterest’s own CEO has said the platform now sends more than five times the clicks it did three years ago, while revenue hasn’t kept pace, and he puts the gap down to attribution. Shoppers save a Pin, come back days later through search, and buy. That’s real, but it also creates room for an agency to tell whatever story it wants.

Two things to know. First, in April 2025 Pinterest removed engagement-based attribution windows, leaving 30-day click plus 1-day view as the default. Second, Pinterest deduplicates tag and Conversions API events only when their event IDs match, so a sloppy setup can double count or drop conversions.

Here’s why the window matters. In a boutique fashion account we run, September’s Pinterest return was about 1.4x on 7-day click only. Add 1-day view and the same month reads close to 5.9x. Neither number is the truth on its own. We show the client both, and we judge the channel on what happens to new-customer revenue in their store. An agency that only ever shows you the bigger number is selling, not reporting.

Tracking breaks more often than people think. When a premium-priced DTC brand reconnected its Shopify store to Pinterest this fall, the catalog came back fine but the tag and Conversions API events didn’t. We caught it before launching conversion campaigns and held the launch until it was fixed, because optimizing on missing purchase data wastes the whole learning period. In a high-volume ecommerce account with a large catalog, we found the tag over-counting page visits by roughly 50% and add-to-carts by about a third, while under-counting checkouts by around 10%. That’s the kind of gap that makes the algorithm chase the wrong shoppers.

How do I know if a Pinterest agency is actually driving new customers?

Ask for a measurement plan before the first dollar goes out. It should include:

  • Blended MER (total revenue divided by total ad spend) as the headline number.
  • MER on new customers only, split by first-order date from your store or CRM.
  • Post-purchase surveys asking where customers first heard about you.
  • Holdout or geo tests once spend justifies them.
  • A third-party attribution tool if you already use one, to compare channels on equal terms.

The new-customer view is where Pinterest earns its place. In that premium-priced DTC account, Pinterest took about 10% of the paid budget in its first weeks and drove roughly a third of site traffic, nearly all of it new visitors. When we compared total MER against new-customer MER by channel, Pinterest’s number barely moved (down about half a percent). The client’s other paid channels dropped far more, between roughly 17% and 25%, because more of their credited revenue came from existing customers. That’s the comparison I’d want from any agency: which channel brings in people who weren’t already buying.

What does a good first 90 days with a Pinterest agency look like?

Here’s the shape we follow. Use it as a yardstick.

  1. Weeks 1 to 2: audit and fix. Tag, Conversions API, event IDs, catalog connection and product data. Agree on baseline MER and new-customer CAC from your store, not from Ads Manager.
  2. Weeks 2 to 3: launch the core structure. Performance+ with a clean catalog, plus a small number of strong creatives. Set the reporting window in writing.
  3. Weeks 3 to 8: let it learn. Expect volatility. Make changes in batches, not daily. Watch leading indicators like click-through rate, add-to-cart rate and cost per checkout.
  4. Ongoing: clean the catalog. Review spend by product. In the large-catalog account mentioned above, a single product was taking more than a quarter of spend without converting. Excluding it was the fastest win of the month.
  5. Weeks 8 to 12: judge on business outcomes. Compare new-customer revenue and blended MER to the baseline. Scale what’s incremental.

If an agency’s plan skips step one or rushes step three, ask why.

Should I hire a Pinterest specialist or a full-service agency?

It depends on how much Pinterest matters to your growth. If Pinterest is a small test next to a large Meta or Google program, a strong generalist with real Pinterest hours can work. If you expect Pinterest to become a meaningful acquisition channel, hire people who have run it at scale and know how the platform works from the inside.

Pinterest’s Business Partners directory is a reasonable place to start. Pinterest says partners are vetted for technical expertise and Pinterest knowledge, though it doesn’t publish the vetting criteria. Treat the listing as a starting filter, then use the questions above.

For context on where we sit: our team includes former Pinterest employees, and we’ve run Pinterest ads since 2017. We focus on ecommerce and B2C lead-gen brands across Google, YouTube, Pinterest and ChatGPT ads. You can see how we run the channel on our Pinterest ads page and results in business terms in our case studies. If you already have an agency and want a second opinion, an account audit or our Scorecard will show whether the basics are in place.

Common questions

How long should I give a Pinterest ads agency before judging results?

Plan on 60 to 90 days. Pinterest learns more slowly than Meta and buyers often convert days after the first click, so early in-platform ROAS undercounts the channel.

What attribution window should a Pinterest agency report on?

Ask for 7-day click-only and Pinterest's default 30-day click plus 1-day view side by side. Then judge the channel on new-customer revenue and blended MER from your store or CRM.

Does being a Pinterest Business Partner mean an agency is good?

It means Pinterest has vetted them for technical expertise. It doesn't tell you who will run your account or how they report, so still ask the questions above.

What should a Pinterest agency fix before launching campaigns?

The Pinterest tag, the Conversions API, event IDs for deduplication, and catalog health. Launching conversion campaigns on broken tracking wastes the learning period.

Pinterest AdsPinterest users are planners and buyers, not passive scrollers. We have run Pinterest ads since 2017 and know how to make the platform scale profitably.How we run it →
Next step

See what Paid Discovery can do for you.

Book a discovery call. We review your accounts before we talk, so you leave with a clear plan whether or not we work together.

For brands spending $10K+/month on ads · 3-month minimum, then month-to-month